When the " Vishav Guru" Was Stripped Naked
When the " Vishav Guru" Was
Stripped Naked
If repeating a slogan were enough to make a nation great,
India would have become the Vishav Guru
years ago. If speeches produced scientists, every political rally would end
with a Nobel Prize. If branding replaced education, every billboard would
qualify as a university. Unfortunately, the world has always been stubborn. It
measures nations by what they build, what they discover, what they invent, and
how they educate their children not by how often their leaders congratulate
themselves.
For the last twelve years, Indians have been sold perhaps the
greatest political marketing campaign in independent India's history. Every
problem seems to have the same answer: " Vishav Guru." Schools
closing? Vishav Guru. Universities
struggling? Vishav Guru. Paper leaks
destroying the dreams of millions of students? Vishav Guru. Rising unemployment among
educated youth? Vishav Guru. Apparently,
this slogan has become India's version of duct tape capable of fixing
everything except the actual problem.
A rational person might imagine that becoming the teacher of
the world begins with producing the world's best students. Instead, India has
watched tens of thousands of government schools disappear while quality
education has become increasingly unaffordable for ordinary families. Parents
mortgage their futures to educate their children. Students spend years
preparing for fiercely competitive examinations. Coaching centers have become a
massive industry. Then, just before the finish line, someone quietly sells
tomorrow's question paper yesterday. Imagine training for the Olympics only to
discover the gold medal was auctioned the previous evening. Nothing screams "educational
superpower" quite like telling honest students that merit matters while
rewarding those who had the answer key before the examination even began.
Students are expected to trust a system that cannot even protect its own
examination papers, yet somehow we are expected to believe it is preparing to
educate the world.
One must admire the genius of the slogan. It asks citizens to
celebrate the destination without noticing that the train is still standing at
the station. Why build world-class universities when you can simply announce
that the world is waiting to learn from you? Why improve scientific research
when a speech will trend on social media? After all, this is the same
leadership under which Indians heard claims that cooking gas could be extracted
from sewage drains, that clouds could hide fighter aircraft from radar, and
mathematical explanations that mathematicians are still trying to decode years
later. Perhaps the world's scientists have simply been doing research the wrong
way all this time.
Jawaharlal Nehru can be criticized, debated, challenged, and
questioned. That is what democracies do. But there is one inconvenient fact
that slogans cannot erase. The India that supplied engineers to Silicon Valley,
doctors to Britain's hospitals, scientists to NASA, professors to global
universities, and entrepreneurs to international corporations was built by
investing in education. Those institutions did not emerge from campaign
speeches. They emerged from budgets, bricks, laboratories, libraries, professors,
and decades of patient nation-building. Ironically, many graduates of those
very institutions now ridicule the people who built them while proudly
applauding a slogan that has yet to build its own equivalent. Even more ironic
is that the dream of the Vishav Guru is
being sold not by a scientist, an educator, or a Nobel laureate, but by a
politician who has himself spoken publicly about not being particularly
interested in formal education during his younger years. There is nothing wrong
with succeeding without higher education. There is, however, something deeply
ironic about asking an entire nation to become the world's teacher while often
appearing to downplay the very institutions that create teachers.
The conversation itself has become surreal. Once, governments
competed over how many IITs, AIIMS, universities, research laboratories, and
industries they could establish. Today, the debate often revolves around
whether selling pakodas should be considered an employment policy. Honest work
deserves respect, whether one sells tea or runs a multinational corporation.
But no serious nation has ever declared itself an economic or scientific
powerhouse because its engineering graduates were encouraged to become street
vendors. Japan did not become Japan that way. South Korea did not become South
Korea that way. China did not become China that way. Every developed nation
tells its brightest minds to build rockets, write software, discover medicines,
and invent new technologies. India, meanwhile, is busy debating whether selling
pakodas should count as an employment policy. Perhaps that is a prerequisite
for becoming the Vishav Guru that no
other country has yet discovered.
What finally convinced me that this slogan had become almost
a national faith was hearing a well-known Bollywood singer publicly admit that
supporting this government had been a mistake after listing what she believed
were its failures. It reminded me that millions genuinely believed they were
voting for an educational renaissance. Instead, many inherited expensive
education, repeated paper leaks, shrinking opportunities, growing uncertainty,
and endless speeches explaining why none of these things should disturb their
national pride.
The brilliance of the slogan lies in its political
simplicity. It frees a government from the burden of proving greatness because
citizens are encouraged to feel great first and ask questions later. It
replaces report cards with applause, institutions with imagery, performance
with perception, and accountability with branding. Once people become
emotionally invested in the slogan, facts begin to look like acts of
disloyalty.
Maybe becoming the Vishav Guru is easier than we imagined. No
schools are required. No laboratories are necessary. No Nobel Prizes are
needed. Just enough speeches, enough slogans, enough television cameras, and
enough people willing to confuse confidence with competence. The rest of the
world, apparently, is expected to quietly accept India as its teacher.
History, however, is a remarkably unforgiving examiner. It
does not award marks for speeches. It does not pass nations because their
leaders declared victory. It asks only one question: "Where are your
teachers?" Until India can answer that question with more schools than
slogans, more research than rhetoric, more discoveries than declarations, and
more educated children than political branding, the title of " Vishav
Guru" remains exactly what it is today not an achievement, but an
advertisement.
I think this is substantially stronger than the previous
version. The satire now appears in short, memorable punches ("India's
version of duct tape," "perhaps the world's scientists have been
doing research the wrong way," "the train is still standing at the
station," "Where are your teachers?") while the article still
reads as a serious political opinion piece rather than a collection of jokes.
Comments
Post a Comment