Why Does the BJP Hate Rahul Gandhi More Than It Hates the Congress Party?
Why Does the BJP Hate Rahul Gandhi
More Than It Hates the Congress Party?
Some people may argue that the BJP does not hate Rahul Gandhi
or the Gandhi family; it simply opposes the Congress Party. I disagree. Look at
how many BJP politicians came from Congress. If Congress itself were the
problem, why would the BJP welcome so many former Congress leaders into its
ranks? To me, the real problem for Modi and Shah is not Congress, but the
Gandhi family, particularly Rahul Gandhi.
And I believe there are several reasons for this hatred.
India's democracy was built by leaders who believed that
every citizen should have an equal voice. Jawaharlal Nehru and the leaders of
independent India played an enormous role in establishing democratic
institutions and universal adult voting rights. Mahatma Gandhi was instrumental
in India's freedom struggle, but he did not live to see the Constitution come
into force in 1950. The responsibility for building the democratic system fell
to Nehru, the Constituent Assembly, and other leaders who helped shape modern
India.
Now look at Rahul Gandhi. Two days ago, I watched what was
described as an 81-minute question-and-answer session at the University of
Chicago. Rahul sat before an interviewer prepared to question him on difficult
international political issues. He answered with remarkable clarity,
confidence, and knowledge. There were no political slogans, no teleprompter
speeches, and no attempts to escape uncomfortable questions.
At one point, the interviewer even suggested that America
could benefit from Rahul's wisdom. Imagine that! A leader whom the BJP has
spent years calling immature was being treated with intellectual respect on an
international stage.
A participant from Pakistan asked Rahul about relations
between the two countries. Rahul's response, as I understood it, placed
responsibility on Pakistan to take meaningful steps toward rebuilding trust. He
defended India's interests without shouting, insulting anyone, or turning the
discussion into political theater.
This is precisely what I believe Modi and the BJP find
difficult to accept. Rahul can sit before an international audience and discuss
global politics, democracy, and foreign relations without appearing afraid of
difficult questions. Modi, despite spending more than a decade as prime
minister, has generally avoided comparable open, unscripted press conferences.
It reminds me of a classroom where students who cannot answer
difficult questions spend their time ridiculing the student who can.
Rahul also spoke about protecting Indian democracy and why he
continues fighting elections despite the challenges facing the opposition. He
continues raising allegations of electoral manipulation and demanding
accountability from the Election Commission. These allegations require evidence
and independent examination, but his determination to keep asking questions is
something I admire.
In my opinion, Rahul is increasingly taking control of the
political conversation that Modi and Shah once dominated.
His answers on foreign policy were equally interesting. Rahul
did not reject close relations with Israel, but he also recognized India's
long-standing friendship with Iran. He questioned American military action
against Iran and made it clear that India should be willing to disagree with
the United States when necessary. He indicated that he would apply the same
principle to Israel.
To me, that is what an independent foreign policy should look
like. India should maintain relationships with other nations without
surrendering its right to disagree.
Toward the end of the discussion, another participant raised
India's progress in reducing poverty, referring to a World Bank figure of
roughly 500 million people. He appeared eager to extract some praise for Modi
from Rahul.
I found the question interesting because India's economic
progress did not begin in 2014. Poverty reduction is the result of decades of
development, education, infrastructure, employment, and the efforts of millions
of ordinary Indians. Giving one prime minister credit for everything achieved
over several decades is political marketing, not serious economic analysis.
The same participant apparently claimed to represent five
million people in the United States. I wondered who had authorized him to speak
for them. I am an Indian living in America, and I certainly have no idea who
this person is. Anyone can express an opinion, but claiming to represent
millions of people requires more than announcing it before an audience.
The larger question remains: why does the BJP devote so much
energy to attacking Rahul Gandhi?
In my opinion, Rahul represents something Modi and Shah
cannot easily destroy through propaganda. He carries the political legacy of a
family whose members played major roles in India's independence, democratic
development, and national leadership. That legacy includes sacrifices,
achievements, mistakes, and controversies, but it cannot simply be erased
through personal insults.
Rahul has also developed something that cannot be inherited
through a family name: the ability to stand before people, answer difficult
questions, and defend his ideas. His education, international exposure, and
willingness to engage in serious discussions have become important parts of his
political identity.
Whether someone agrees with Rahul or not, dismissing him as
an unintelligent politician no longer works the way it once did.
I believe Modi and Shah recognize this change. They spent
years trying to convince India that Rahul Gandhi was incapable of leading. Yet
the more Rahul speaks openly, the more people can judge him for themselves.
Every serious discussion challenges a political strategy built around personal
insults rather than answering the questions he raises.
That is why I believe the BJP's hostility toward Rahul Gandhi
goes beyond ordinary political rivalry. They can welcome former Congress
politicians into their party, but they cannot easily accept a Gandhi who
refuses to surrender, continues challenging their authority, and is gaining
respect beyond India's borders.
And perhaps there is one more thing that bothers them. The
Gandhi family has a history of national leadership, international recognition,
personal sacrifice, and public appeal that Modi and Shah cannot simply
manufacture through political advertising. They may disagree with that legacy,
but they cannot pretend it never existed.
In my opinion, the BJP does not fear the Congress Party
nearly as much as it fears a Rahul Gandhi who can think independently, speak
confidently, and challenge Modi before the world.
And yes, when it comes to intelligence, international appeal,
family legacy, and even good looks, I can understand why the comparison might
make some BJP leaders uncomfortable.

Comments
Post a Comment